Chignell
[at] cornell.edu Ithaca,
NY 14853 Tel: (607) 255-6819
![]()
Positions
July 1, 2009-present: Associate
Professor, Sage School of Philosophy, Cornell University
*also
appointed in the Religious Studies and Cognitive Science programs
Jan. 1, 2004-June 30,
2009: Assistant Professor, Sage School of Philosophy, Cornell University
July 1, 2006-July 1,
2007: Mellon Foundation Member, School of Historical Studies,
Institute
for Advanced Study, Princeton
Sept. 1 - Dec. 31,
2003: Instructor, Sage School of Philosophy, Cornell University
Education
Ph.D., Yale
University, 2004
Visiting student, Humboldt Universität zu Berlin,
Institut für Philosophie, 2002-2003
Visiting student, Harvard University, Philosophy
Dept., Spring 1998
M.Phil. Yale University
(Philosophy and Religious Studies), May 2000
M.A. Yale University
(Philosophy), May 1999
M.A. Yale University
(Religious Studies), May 1998
B.A. summa cum laude,
Wheaton College (Philosophy, English Literature, Religion), May 1996
Areas of
Specialization
Kant, modern philosophy
Areas of Competence
Epistemology, aesthetics,
philosophy of religion
Research
Articles, Contributions
21. “Kant between the wars,”
Philosophical Forum, special edition
on early 20th century developments in German philosophy, eds. P. Gilgen and P. Hohendahl
(forthcoming)
20. “Real repugnance and
belief about things-in-themselves: Kant’s three solutions,” in Kant’s Moral
Metaphysics, eds. B. Lipscomb and J. Krueger. Berlin: deGruyter
(forthcoming).
19. “Real repugnance
and knowledge of things-in-themselves: A Lockean
problem in Kant and Hegel,” in Internationales Jahrbuch des deutschen Idealismus, vol. 7 (forthcoming)
18. “The ethics
of belief,” Stanford
Encyclopedia of Philosophy (forthcoming)
17. “Causal
refutations of idealism,“ Philosophical Quarterly (forthcoming)
16. “Descartes on sensation:
A defense of the semantic-causation model,” Philosophers’ Imprint 9 (5), June 2009: 1-22
15. “Kant, modality,
and the most real being,” Archiv für Geschichte der Philosophie 91 (2), June
2009.
14. “Are supersensibles really possible? The evidential role of
symbols,” Recht und Frieden in der
Philosophie Kants, eds. V.
Rhoden, T. Terra, G. Almeida. Berlin: DeGruyter,
2009.
13. “’As Kant has
shown’: analytic theology and the critical philosophy,” in M. Rea and O. Crisp,
eds. Analytic
Theology, New York: Oxford UP, 2009.
12. “On going back to
Kant,” Philosophical
Forum 39 (2), June 2008: 109-124 (introduction to special edition on Neo-
Kantianism, eds. A Chignell, T. Irwin and T.Teufel).
11. “Neo-Kantian
philosophy of science: Cassirer, Kuhn, and Friedman,” Philosophical Forum 39 (2), June 2008:
253-262 (part of special edition on Neo-Kantianism, eds. A. Chignell, T. Irwin,
T. Teufel).
10.”Kant on the normativity of taste: the role of aesthetic ideas” Australasian
Journal of Philosophy 85 (3), Sep 2007: 415-433.
9. “Belief in Kant,” Philosophical
Review 116 (3), July 2007: 323-360.
8. “Kant’s concepts of
justification,” Nous
41 (1), March 2007: 33-63.
7. “Beauty as a symbol
of natural systematicity,” British Journal of Aesthetics 46 (4),
Oct 2006: 406-415.
6. “The ethics of
religious belief,” (with Andrew Dole), in God and the Ethics of Belief, A.Chignell and A. Dole, eds. New York: Cambridge UP, 2005, 1-32.
5. “Accidentally true
belief and warrant,” Synthese, 137 (3), Dec 2003: 445-458.
4. “Infant suffering
revisited,” Religious
Studies 37 (4), Dec 2001: 475-484.
3. “The problem of
particularity in Kant’s aesthetics,” in Kevin L. Stoehr,
ed. Proceedings
of the World Congress of Philosophy. Bowling Green: Philosophy Documentation Center, 2000.
2. “The problem of
infant suffering,” Religious Studies 34 (2), May 1998: 205-217.
1. “Ockham on
mind-world relations: What sort of
nominalism?” Eidos 14 (1), (Jan 1997):11-28.
Edited volumes
2. Special edition of Philosophical
Forum on Neo-Kantianism, June 2008. (co-edited with Terence Irwin and
Thomas Teufel)
Contributors:
Paul Guyer, Rolf-Peter Horstmann,
Peter Gordon, Dina Emundts, Vasilis
Politis, Michael Friedman, Peter Gilgen,
Frederick Beiser, Michelle Kosch.
1. God and the Ethics
of Belief: New Essays in Philosophy of Religion (co-edited with Andrew
Dole). New York: Cambridge UP,
2005 (paperback 2009).
Contributors:
Alvin Plantinga, Nicholas Wolterstorff,
Philip Quinn, Linda Zagzebski, Derk
Pereboom, Keith DeRose,
Richard Swinburne, Peter van Inwagen, John Hare,
Robert Audi.
Other
6. Eleven entries in
the Kant-Lexikon, eds. Mohr, Stolzenberg,
Willaschek. Berlin: Walter de
Gruyter (forthcoming, 2010).
5. “Postulate des empirischen Denkens,” with
Nicholas Stang.
In Kant-Lexikon, eds.
Mohr,
Stolzenberg, Willaschek.
Berlin: Walter de Gruyter (forthcoming, 2010).
4. Review of Georges
Dicker, Kant’s
Theory of Knowledge (Oxford, 2004), in Philosophical
Review, April 2007.
3. Review of A. W.
Moore, Noble
in Reason, Infinite in Faculty: Themes and Variations in
Kant’s Moral and
Religious Philosophy (Routledge, 2003), in Philosophical Review, Jan 2006.
2. Review of H.J. Glock (ed.), Strawson and Kant (Oxford, 2003), Notre Dame
Philosophical
Reviews,
July
2004.
1. Entries on “Thomas
Reid” and “George Santayana” in Religion in Geschichte und
Gegenwart, 4. Auflage, Tübingen:
Mohr Siebeck, 2004.
In preparation: articles
7. “The religious
sublime,” in The Sublime, ed. T.
Costello (under contract with Cambridge Press)
6. Long critical
notice of E. Watkins, Kant and the
Metaphysics of Causality and E. Watkins, Kant’s Critique of Pure Reason: Background Source Materials for Philosophical Review (with D. Pereboom)
5. “Can Kant
reasonably prefer Milton to Ogilby?”
4. “How naturalistic
is Humean representation?”
3. “Kant, real
possibility, and the threat of Spinoza”
2. “Skepticism,
content, and Kant”
1. “Natural theology,”
invited for Stanford
Encyclopedia of Philosophy
In preparation: volumes
2. What May I Hope?
Commissioned by Routledge as part of the series: Kant’s Five Questions, general editor Allen Wood (under contract)
1. Invited guest
editor (with Tim Costello), Journal of Scottish Philosophy (spring 2011). Topic: Scottish and German aesthetics.
Presentations
Upcoming 2009-2010:
presentations at University of Illinois--Chicago, University of Pennsylvania,
Boston University, University of Tuebingen,
Universities of Qom and Imam Sadeq (Tehran)
American Society for
Aesthetics, APA Pacific Division meeting, Vancouver (April 2009)
“Can
Kant reasonably prefer Milton to Ogilby?” (Bradley
Murray, commentator)
Philosophy of
Religion: Eastern and Western Contexts conference, Hong Kong (February 2009)
“Liturgical
philosophy of religion”
University of Notre
Dame, Philosophy Dept. Colloquium (December 2008)
“Kant,
real possibility, and the threat of Spinoza”
Yale University,
Society for Early Modern Philosophy at Yale (September 2008)
“Kant,
real possibility, and the threat of Spinoza”
Margaret D. Wilson
Conference in Early Modern Philosophy, Cornell University (June 2008)
“Skepticism,
Kant, and content”
New York University,
Philosophy Dept. Summer Symposium, La Pietra, Italy
(June 2008)
“Skepticism,
Kant, and Content” (Dina Emundts, commentator)
Boston University,
Institute for Philosophy and Religion (April 2008)
“Liturgical
philosophy”
Princeton University,
graduate seminar on Kant’s third Critique (March 2008)
“Kant
on taste”
Northwestern
University, Philosophy Dept. Colloquium
(December 2007)
“Kant,
modality, and moral belief”
University of Toronto,
Philosophy Dept. Colloquium (November 2007)
“Kant,
modality, and the most real being”
Syracuse University,
Upstate New York Early Modern Philosophy Workshop (April 2007)
“The
real possibility of supersensibles”
Princeton Theological
Seminary, Philosophy Colloquium (March 2007)
“Kant
on beauty: the sensible and beyond”
Institute for Advanced
Study, Princeton, School of Historical Studies (March 2007)
“Just
a taste of Kant”
Belief and Metaphysics conference, Instituto de
Filosofía de Edith Stein de Granada, Spain
(September 2006)
“Belief,
metaphysics, and Kant”
The Enlightenment
project revisited conference,
Houghton College (May 2006)
“The
real possibility of supersensibles”
American Philosophical
Association, Central Division NAKS session (April 2006)
“Kant
on the kinds of knowledge” (Anja Jauernig,
commentator)
University of
Binghamton (December 2005)
“Belief
in Kant”
American Academy of
Religion, Religion
and German Idealism section (November 2005)
“Kant
on beauty as a religious symbol” (Terry Pinkard,
commentator)
10th
International Kant Congress, Sao Paulo Brazil (September 2005)
“Are
supersensibles really possible? Kant on the
evidential role of symbols”
Max-Planck Institute,
Berlin (July 2005) (workshop presentation)
“Kant’s ethics of assent”
Institute for German Idealism,
Humboldt Universität zu Berlin (June 2005)
“Rechtfertigung
bei Kant”
North American Kant
Society, Pacific Study Group, Pomona College (November 2004)
“Kant’s
ethics of assent”
North American Kant
Society, Eastern Study Group, Fordham University (April 2004)
“Belief
in Kant”
North American Kant
Society, Midwest Study Group, Notre Dame (October 2003)
“Kant’s concepts of justification”
Kant und Hegel Kolloquium, Humboldt Universität zu Berlin (July 2003)
“Der einzig
mögliche Beweisgrund und das ens realissimum als
Geist”
American Academy of
Religion Annual Meeting, Toronto (November 2002)
“Two
religious ethics of belief: Immanuel Kant and Thomas Reid”
American Philosophical
Association Eastern Division, New York City (December 2000)
“Descartes
on perception: the role of natural signs” (Marleen Rozemond, commentator)
University of
Aberdeen, International Thomas Reid Symposium, (July 2000)
“Reid
on other minds”
Brown University, grad
philosophy conference (February 2000)
“Do
we perceive other minds?”
World Congress of
Philosophy, Boston (August 1998)
“The
problem of particularity in Kant’s aesthetics”
Arizona State
University, Society of Christian Philosophers (March 1998)
“Worries
about divine impassibility”
University of Colorado
at Boulder, Society of Christian Philosophers (April 1997)
“The
problem of infant suffering”
Rutgers University,
graduate philosophy conference (April 1997)
“Must
our values be objective?”
Commentaries
NYU Early Modern
Philosophy Conference (November 2008)
“Jonathan
Vogel’s Refutation of Idealism”
Legacy of Kant II:
Kant between the World Wars conference, Cornell (October 2008)
“Peter
Hohendahl on the crisis of Neo-Kantianism between the
wars”
Cornell Philosophy
Discussion Club (October 2007)
“Georges
Dicker’s Refutation of Idealism”
Legacy of Kant I:
Classical Neo-Kantianism conference, Cornell (September 2007)
“Michael
Friedman on Kuhn and Cassirer”
American Academy of
Religion Annual Meeting, Washington D.C. (November 2006)
“Kelly
Clark’s tolerance”
Cornell discussion
club (November 2005)
“Don
Garrett on Hume’s naturalism”
American Philosophical
Association Pacific Division, San Francisco (April 2005)
“Alex
Rueger and Sahan Evren on Kantian symbolization”
Free will conference, Wheaton College
(October 2004)
“Derk Pereboom’s argument against
moral responsibility”
Cornell Philosophy
Discussion Club (April 2004)
“John
McDowell on transcendental arguments”
American Philosophical
Association Pacific Division, Seattle (March 2002)
“Martin
Schönfeld on Kant’s possibility proof”
Teaching
Cornell: courses
Phil 681/481: Graduate
seminar: Recent analytic Hegelianism (co-taught with Richard Boyd, Spring 2010)
Phil 651: Graduate
seminar: The problem of evil (co-taught with Scott MacDonald, Fall 2005)
Phil 642: Graduate
seminar: Kant’s Critique
of the Power of Judgment (Spring 2009)
Phil 609/409:
Translation seminar: German philosophical texts
2005-6:
Fall:
First four ‘moments’ of Kant’s Kritik der Urteilskraft
Spring:
Vorrede to Hegel’s Phaenomenologie des Geistes
2007-8:
Fall:
Introduction to Schelling’s System des transzendentalen Idealismus
Spring:
Wittgenstein’s Ueber Gewissheit
2008-9:
Fall:
B-Preface to Kant’s Kritik der reinen Vernunft
Spring:
Selections from Kant’s Kritik der Urteilskraft and Heidegger’s Sein und Zeit
Phil 416: Topics in
German philosophy: Kant’s philosophy of religion (Spring 2004)
Phil 311: The
rationalists (Fall 2004, Spring 2008, Spring 2010)
Phil 316: Kant’s Critique of Pure
Reason (Fall
2003, Fall 2004, Fall 2008)
Phil 212: Modern
philosophy (Spring 2004, Spring 2006, Spring 2008)
Phil 100: The ethics
of belief (Fall 2007)
Phil 100: The examined
life (Fall 2003)
Cornell Telluride
Winter Program: Kierkegaard’s Either-Or (Intensive course, Jan 2004)
Cornell: advising
Dissertation
committees
1.
Lawrence Bruce-Robertson, Topic: Hegel (2004-present)
2.
Mark Fedyk, Topic: The Epistemology and Psychology of
Intuitions (2006-present)
3.
Rachel Lu, Topic: The Virtue of Hope in Bonaventure (2006-present)
4.
Sydney Penner, Topic: Suarez (2007-present)
Senior Theses
1.
Chloe Layman, Topic: Leibniz and Chinese Philosophy (2005-6)
2.
Wesley Mattingly, Topic: Transcendental Arguments Past and Present (2005-6)
Other Independent
Studies
1.
Michael Barton-Sweeney, Topic: Skepticism
2.
Ben Carter and Ian Wells, Topic: Spinoza’s Ethics, books I and II
3.
Marc Franzoni, Topic: Wittgenstein’s Blue Book
4.
Devin Conathan, Topic: Kant’s theory of experience
Yale: as instructor
Metaphysical idealism
in Indian and European Philosophy (Spring 2001)
Ethics (Summer 2000)
Yale: as teaching fellow
Philosophy of religion
(Fall 2000)
Medieval philosophy
(Spring 2000)
Kant (Fall 1999)
Service
To the Department
Director of Undergraduate
Studies, Philosophy dept. (2008-9)
Coordinator,
Philosophy Discussion Club (2005-6, Spring 2008, 2008-9)
Member, Standing
Committee on Faculty Appointments, Philosophy Dept. (2005-present)
Member, Philosophy
search committees (2004-5, 2005-6)
Book review committee,
Philosophical
Review (2004-5, chair 2005-6)
Faculty adviser, Logos: The
Cornell Undergraduate Journal of Philosophy (2004-present)
Member, Graduate
admissions committee (2003-4, 2007-8)
Coordinator,
Department Workshop, Philosophy Dept. (Fall 2007, 2009-2010)
To the University
Faculty fellow,
Jameson Hall (2007-present)
Member, Undergraduate
admissions committee, College of Arts and Sciences (Spring 2009)
Speaker, Cornell Sage
Chapel Interfaith service (Sept 2007)
Member, Steering committee,
Institute for German Cultural Studies (2005-9)
Resident faculty,
Telluride House at Cornell (2003-2005)
Resident graduate
fellow, Berkeley College at Yale (1999-2002)
To the Profession
Co-coordinator,
Upstate New York Early Modern Workshop (2008-present)
Co-organizer with
Peter Gilgen, “The Labor of the Concept”: A Workshop
on the Preface to
Hegel’s
Phenomenology
(March 2008)
Co-organizer with
Terence Irwin, Conference on “The Legacy of Kant: Classical Neo-
Kantianism”
(Sept 2007)
Member, Editorial
board, Philosophical
Review (Fall 2003-present)
Referee, in some cases
multiple times, for Australasian Journal of Philosophy, Journal of Religion,
Philosophical Review, Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, Journal of the
History of
Philosophy, Journal of the American
Academy of Religion,
Faith and
Philosophy, Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism,
Routledge UP,
Cambridge UP, Princeton UP, Oxford UP, Ashgate Press.
Fellowships, Awards
Summer Seminar,
“Philosophical reflections on liturgy,” Calvin College.
Directors:
Nicholas Wolterstorff, Terence Cuneo (June-July 2009)
NEH Summer Seminar,
“Scottish and German Aesthetics,” University of St. Andrews.
Directors: Paul Guyer, Rachel Zuckert. (July-August 2007)
Junior Faculty Research
Grant, Institute for European Studies, Cornell (summer 2007)
Mellon Fellowship for
Assistant Professors, Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton (2006-7)
Cornell faculty
exchange program to Humboldt Universität zu Berlin (summer 2006)
Participant, year-long
Faculty Mellon Seminar, Society for Humanities (2005-6)
National Endowment for
the Humanities, Summer Stipend (2005)
Society for Humanities
at Cornell, faculty traveling research grant (to Germany) (2005)
NEH Summer Institute,
“17th Century Philosophy, Science, Theology,” University of
Wisconsin
-Madison.
Directors: Donald Rutherford, Steven Nadler (July 2004).
Society of Fellows,
Princeton University, 3-year post-doctoral fellowship (2003-2006) (declined)
Fulbright full
fellowship, Germany (2002-2003)
Mrs. Giles Whiting
Fellowship in the Humanities, Yale (2001-2002)
APA Eastern division,
Graduate student travel award (2000)
Eileen Harvey Graduate
Fellowship (1998-2001)
Pew Charitable Trusts
Younger Scholar (1997-2001)
Andrew W. Mellon
Fellowship in Humanistic Studies (1996-1997)
References
Robert M. Adams,
Oxford (robert.adams@mansfield.ox.ac.uk)
Michael Della Rocca, Yale (michael.della@yale.edu)
Gail Fine, Cornell
(gjf1@cornell.edu)
Hannah Ginsborg (ginsborg@berkeley.edu)
Michelle Kosch, Cornell (mak229@cornell.edu)
Derk Pereboom,
Cornell (dp346@cornell.edu)
Eric Watkins, UC-San
Diego (ewatkins@ucsd.edu)
Nicholas Wolterstorff, Yale
(nicholas.wolterstorff@yale.edu)
Allen Wood, Stanford (allen.wood@stanford.edu)
Teaching References
Graduate students:
Saul
Rosenthal (sgr7@cornell.edu)
Kathryn
Waidler (kdw22@cornell.edu)
Lawrence
Bruce-Robertson (lb94@cornell.edu)
Undergraduate
students:
Chloe
Layman (cl2487@columbia.edu)
Wesley
Mattingly (wesley.mattingly@gmail.com)
Reza
Mahmoodshahi (reza.mahmoodshahi@gmail.com)
Daniel
Ranweiler (djr236@cornell.edu)